Univ. Waterloo Department of C & O Program Requirements

last-updated-05-Feb-2006

(disclaimer: I completed by degree requirements in December 2004. It's possible that the current requirements have changed.)

While I was working on my Ph.D., I used this web page to keep track of the various program requirements I had and had not completed.

The official documentation explaining the degree requirements for a Ph.D. in Combinatorics & Optimization can be found in the graduate calendar. Passages highlighted in blue below are quoted directly from this source.

Here are the main requirements:


Course Work

Eight courses, including:
2 of C&O 630, C&O 634, C&O 642, C&O 644
1 of C&O 650, C&O 652
1 of C&O 663, C&O 666
1 additional course from C&O 630, C&O 634, C&O 642, C&O 644, C&O 650, C&O 652, C&O 663, C&O 666, C&O 685

At least 5 of the 8 courses taken for credit toward the degree must be C&O courses.

Status: completed, Spring 2002

Here are the course I've taken to meet this requirement:

Return to top


Research Skills Seminar

In the department, this seminar is usually called "the grad student seminar". Masters and PhD students new to the department participate in the seminar. Each student gives a short talk and their presentation is evaluated by the other participants.
Required for the PhD students in C&O unless the student satisfied this requirement as a MMath student at the C&O department.

Status: completed during MMath degree

Return to top


First Stage Comprehensive Exam

The first stage is a written examination covering the fundamentals of combinatorics and optimization. These are usually offered once a year, in the spring term. The student must write one exam from two of the following three categories:

Combinatorial Enumeration, Graph Theory
Continuous Optimization, Discrete Optimization
Cryptography, Quantum Computing

(The choice of exams is made by the student, in consultation with their supervisor.)

The first stage of the comprehensives must be taken within four terms of the student's first registration in the PhD program. The [first stage] Comprehensive Examination Requirement is satisfied by passing both examinations.

There are several different choices a student can make in satisfying this requirement. Once a category is chosen there is a further choice of which exam to write in that category. For example, a student who choses the Optimization category then decides to write either the continuous optimization exam or the discrete optimization exam (but not both).

Status: completed, Spring 2002

Here are the exams I chose to write:

Return to top


Second Stage Comprehensive Exam

The second stage comprehensive is an oral exam at which the student is expected to give a brief description of the questions they propose to work on for the PhD and a summary of the main results in this area. A handout giving more details is available from the Graduate Secretary. This exam should normally be taken within one year of completing the first-stage of the comprehensives. It must be taken at least one full term before the PhD defence is scheduled.

Before you can do your second stage comprehensive exam you must form an advisory committee:

Each student has an Advisory Committee, which normally consists of the student's supervisor and two other department members with expertise in the area of the student's research interests. The Advisory Committee acts as the examining committee at the student's second stage comprehensive examination, and is usually formed at this time. The members of the advisory committee will also usually act as examiners at the student's PhD defence. The Advisory Committee is selected by the Graduate Officer, who will consult the student and their supervisor.

Status: completed, Spring 2003

My advisory committee consists of:

My exam was held 26 June 2003 at 10:30am in MC 5158.

Return to top


Lecturing Requirement

Every PhD student will be required to lecture under supervision during the program of studies. If a PhD student gives a scheduled course on a regular basis, the same two faculty members will attend three of the lectures and make a confidential, constructive critique of the student's performance to the student.

The candidate may not put the thesis on display until at least the term following that in which the Lecturing Requirement was successfully completed.

Status: completed, Spring 2004

Here are the lectures I gave:

Return to top


Thesis Requirement

The candidate must prepare a thesis, embodying the results of original research, of a standard that would warrant publication in a research journal of the field. The thesis must be acceptable to the student's supervisor, to two professors in the Department and one professor outside the Department, and to an external examiner familiar with the student's research field. The student is required to defend the thesis at an oral examination. This requirement is met when the thesis has been successfully defended and accepted.

Status: completed, December 2004.

Here are some important dates:

The result of my oral examination was that my thesis was accepted. After incorporating the changes suggested by my examiners, I submitted my revised thesis for binding on 22 December 2004. You can view the final version of my thesis here.

Return to top


back to James Muir's home page